23. Richie Hebner
Richie Hebner was a model of consistency throughout his MLB career, but consistency does not get you much personal acclaim. Hebner averaged roughly 15 home runs, 60 RBI and 60 runs scored a season and was a career .276 hitter.
He may not have been an All-Star but Hebner was a reliable starting corner infielder in the big league for 18 years.