The 20 Best Players Who Never Made a Pro Bowl

16. Amani Toomer

Amani Toomer never got much credit outside of the tri-state area for his production at the wide receiver position, but any Giants fan knows just how good Toomer was at his best.

Toomer became a starter in 1999 and put together five seasons in which he eclipsed 1,000 receiving yards each year and totaled 374 catches.